Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)

IY 3 months ago

This was my first time trying actual NY pizza in NY, I was not let down, when first walking in i was hit with the most amazing smell ever, all of the pizzas on display looked amazing and i genuinely wanted to get a slice of each. They have both rectangular slices and normal pizza slices but they all looked equally as delicious. When I got my pizza and tried it, it was amazing, when I visit NYC again I will definitely come back here!!

R Davis 5 months ago

I will walk all over Manhattan to get to Mimi's Pizza. They have the best pizza. The crust is crispy not soggy. Sauce and cheese flavor and ratio is perfect. Counter seating, 2 small tables outside.

Sean Morgan 8 months ago

A tight but great place. Line was very quick and staff were straightforward and efficient. Flavors of pizza were varied and good quality overall. Highly recommend any of their square slices as had nice crisp to the dough and flavors were on point. Seating is counter style against the side wall which felt a bit cramped but adds to the vibe in a way.

David Lazar 11 months ago

Fantastic UES pizza! We stopped in for a snack after visiting the Guggenheim and it did not disappoint. We just grabbed a few slices of what was already made: a sausage and pepperoni slice and a pepperoni deep dish square slice. It can be hard to figure out what pizza in New York is actually good but this place is the real deal. Perfect crunch, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. The price was right and so was the wait! Give them a try

Carly Pisarri a year ago

I popped in after work before I hopped on the train. I was hungry and needed something to hold me till dinner and let me tell you…this pizza HIT. I had low expectations, they don’t even really have a noticeable sign. Sicilian usually isn’t my thing but the pesto vodka slice was calling my name. The crust was perfectly crispy. Slightly doughy on the inside. Every bite I wanted more. I’ll def be back!